Navigating Cultural Differences in Your Muslim Identity

﷽

One of the biggest challenges in your learning journey is distinguishing between what is truly Islamic and what is cultural. You will be hearing advice from Muslims of different backgrounds. You may also notice subtle ways in which they practice Islam differently. Sometimes these practices come purely from tradition, which may leave you feeling confused or isolated. 

Rest assured that you can maintain your cultural identity while embracing Islamic values. Culture and Islam naturally mix into people’s lifestyles. What is important is being able to distinguish the two as you navigate different environments. 

Understanding Islam’s Universality From a Cultural Lens

Islam was revealed for all of humanity—timeless, adaptable, and applicable across every culture and generation. The Qur’an and Sunnah provide universal principles, but within those principles, there is space for cultural diversity. Islam doesn’t erase culture—it purifies and elevates it.

This means that as a revert, you don’t have to abandon your heritage. In fact, Islam gives great importance to genealogy and heritage, and honours customs that do not go against Islamic teachings. Enjoying traditional foods, wearing cultural clothing, or celebrating family milestones can all continue, just with modifications if something clashes with Islamic values. 

The Prophet’s companions came from diverse cultures: Bilal was from Abyssinia (modern-day Ethiopia), Salman Al-Farsi was from Persia, and Suhayb Ar-Rumi came from the Byzantine Empire. Each of them embraced Islam while retaining aspects of their cultural identity.

Today, Islam spans every corner of the globe. Beyond Arab and South Asian cultures, Islam flourishes among Uyghurs and Hui Muslims in China, Indonesians, Malaysians, Bosniaks, Chechens, Uzbeks, Senegalese, Nigerians, Somalis, Turks, and many more. Every predominantly Muslim country has its own unique culture, showing that no single group “owns” Islam. Yet, many outsiders and even some Muslims mistakenly view Islam as limited to Arab or Desi traditions. In reality, Islam is a universal faith that thrives in diverse cultural expressions.

Islam vs. Culture: Defining the Line

It’s common for Muslims to confuse aspects of their culture with religion. Sometimes practices get passed down as “Islamic,” even though they are simply cultural customs. For example, certain wedding traditions, gender roles, or expectations around clothing may come from culture, not the Quran or Sunnah.

For reverts, it’s important to learn to distinguish the two. Trusted resources, such as scholars, teachers, mentors, and reliable books, can help clarify what is truly a part of Islam. You can also seek out Muslims who are supportive, knowledgeable, and open-minded, rather than those who impose cultural practices as mandatory. 

The goal is not to pit culture against religion, but to allow them to coexist harmoniously.

The Pressure to “Arabize” or “Desi-fy” Islam

You may sometimes feel that the way you live Islam isn’t as valid if it doesn’t resemble the culture of the majority Muslim communities, often Arab or Desi. You may even feel pressured by born Muslims to adopt certain foods, clothing, or languages. 

It’s important to remember that no one culture owns Islam. You don’t need to eat biryani or wear a thobe, to be a “real Muslim.” Your cultural clothes, language, and traditional food are meaningful parts of who you are, and Islam encourages you to cherish them as long as they align with Islamic principles.

The Qur’an itself affirms the value of diversity: “O humanity! Indeed, We created you from a male and a female, and made you into peoples and tribes so that you may ˹get to˺ know one another.” [^https://quran.com/al-hujurat/13]

This verse reminds us that cultural variety is not only acceptable, but part of Allah’s design for humanity.

Unfortunately, you might experience exclusion or feel like an outsider, being seen as a novelty, exotic, or perpetual beginner. This can be hurtful. Acknowledge this pain, and remember that your worth as a Muslim is defined first and foremost by your sincerity with Allah, not by others’ assumptions. You can also seek out spaces and communities that value inclusivity and welcome you as you are. If someone treats you dismissively, set gentle boundaries by redirecting the conversation with kindness, and when possible, use it as an opportunity to educate with wisdom. Sometimes other Muslims may not realize how their words or behaviour come across.

When Your Culture Clashes with Islamic Values

Sometimes, parts of your cultural background may contradict Islamic teachings. For example, cultural dishes that involve pork will need to be adjusted or replaced.  

When you’re unsure about a practice, ask yourself:

• Does this practice harm myself or others?
• Is this practice rooted in injustice or unethical behaviour?
• Is this practice tied to beliefs or rituals that go against worshipping Allah alone?
• Does this practice involve the consumption of haram products?

Letting go of harmful traditions doesn’t mean abandoning your culture. It means reshaping it in a way that honours both your heritage and your faith.

Creating a New Norm

You can find creative ways to reframe cultural practices. Weddings can be faith-centered while still retaining cultural beauty. Family gatherings can preserve their customs, while un-Islamic elements are replaced with halal alternatives.

Islam emphasizes maintaining family ties, even with non-Muslim relatives. Practical ways to do this include celebrating shared values, communicating with compassion, and inviting your family into Islamic-friendly activities. However, if family hostility becomes overwhelming, it’s okay to set boundaries and seek support through dua, community, and patience.

You can also find cultural comfort zones. Look for communities where you feel seen, such as revert circles, inclusive mosques, or online spaces that celebrate diversity. These environments remind you that your Muslim identity doesn’t need to erase your cultural background.

As a revert, one of your biggest strengths is your ability to become a bridge between cultures and customs. You can help your non-Muslim family understand Islam in relatable ways, while also showing fellow Muslims the richness of cultural diversity beyond their own traditions. Your unique gift as a revert is seeing Islam with new lenses.

Honour Your Roots While Living Faithfully

You don’t have to choose between your culture and your faith. Islam welcomes diversity and allows you to honour your roots while living faithfully. 

Walk proudly in your unique Muslim journey. Remember that Allah sees your every effort and sincerity, and He loves those who struggle in His path.